CIL vs CIP Gold Recovery: Differences, Pros and the Right Activated Carbon

Carbon-in-leach (CIL) and carbon-in-pulp (CIP) are the two most widely used ways to recover gold from cyanide leach slurry. Both use activated carbon to adsorb dissolved gold, and both feed…

Tuesday, 10 Nov 2026

CIL vs CIP Gold Recovery: Differences, Pros and the Right Activated Carbon

Carbon-in-leach (CIL) and carbon-in-pulp (CIP) are the two most widely used ways to recover gold from cyanide leach slurry. Both use activated carbon to adsorb dissolved gold, and both feed the same elution and regeneration steps. The difference is where and when the carbon meets the pulp, and that choice affects plant size, recovery and how hard the carbon has to work.

This guide explains how each process works, when one is better than the other, and what to look for in the carbon.

How CIP works

In a CIP plant, leaching and adsorption happen in separate stages.

  1. The ground ore slurry is leached with cyanide in a series of leach tanks, usually for many hours, until most of the gold has dissolved.
  2. The leached pulp then flows through a separate train of adsorption tanks containing activated carbon.
  3. Carbon moves counter-current to the pulp, from the last tank towards the first, picking up more gold at each step.
  4. Loaded carbon is screened out of the first tank and sent to elution, then regeneration, then back to the circuit.

How CIL works

In a CIL plant, leaching and adsorption happen in the same tanks.

  1. Carbon is added directly to the leach tanks, so gold is adsorbed as soon as it dissolves.
  2. Carbon still moves counter-current to the pulp, and loaded carbon is removed from the first tank for elution.
  3. There is usually a short pre-leach stage before the first carbon tank.

The key differences

CIP CIL
Leach and adsorption Separate tank trains Same tanks
Number of tanks More Fewer
Capital cost Higher Lower
Gold in solution Builds up before adsorption Adsorbed as it dissolves
Preg-robbing ores Less suited Better suited
Carbon residence time Shorter Longer
Carbon wear Lower Higher (longer time in agitated tanks)

When CIL is the better choice

  • Preg-robbing ores: ores containing natural carbonaceous material can re-adsorb dissolved gold and lose it to the tailings. In CIL, the added activated carbon captures the gold first.
  • Lower capital cost: one tank train instead of two.
  • Simpler layout: useful for new plants and smaller operations.

When CIP is the better choice

  • Fast-leaching ores that are not preg-robbing, where separate stages let each step be optimised.
  • Lower carbon inventory and wear: carbon spends less time in the agitated leach environment.
  • Higher gold in solution at the adsorption stage, which can give higher carbon loading.

Many plants use a hybrid: a few leach-only tanks followed by CIL tanks.

Choosing activated carbon for CIL and CIP

Whichever process you run, the carbon has to adsorb gold quickly, survive months of agitation and keep its activity through repeated elution and regeneration.

  • Raw material: coconut shell carbon is the standard for gold recovery because it is hard and rich in the small pores that adsorb gold-cyanide. Read coconut shell vs coal activated carbon.
  • Mesh size: 6×12 and 8×16 US mesh are the common sizes. Coarser 6×12 carbon is easier to screen from the pulp; finer 8×16 carbon adsorbs gold faster. Your screen apertures decide the minimum size.
  • Hardness: carbon that breaks down in the tanks creates fines that carry gold to the tailings. This matters most in CIL, where carbon stays longer in the leach tanks. Look for high ball-pan hardness.
  • Activity: high activity (often reported as iodine number or CTC) means faster gold loading.
  • Regeneration: carbon loses activity as it picks up organics and scale. Regular thermal regeneration and acid washing restore it.

Our FM MAXGOLD is a coconut shell activated carbon made for CIL, CIP and CIC circuits, in 6×12 and 8×16 mesh, with hardness above 98% and iodine number above 1100 mg/g.

Reducing carbon and gold losses

  • Screen carbon properly between tanks and check inter-stage screens for wear.
  • Condition new carbon (attrition and screening) before it goes into the circuit to remove fines.
  • Track carbon losses per tonne of ore treated; a rising figure points to soft carbon or worn screens.
  • Keep regeneration temperatures and residence times in range so the carbon keeps its activity without being damaged.

How First Molecule can help

We supply FM MAXGOLD and other activated carbons to mining operations across Africa, Asia and the Middle East. Send us your process type (CIL, CIP or CIC), screen sizes and current carbon loss rate, and our team will recommend a grade. Contact us

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between CIL and CIP?

In CIP, gold is leached first and adsorbed onto carbon in separate tanks. In CIL, leaching and adsorption happen in the same tanks at the same time.

Which is better, CIL or CIP?

CIL usually costs less to build and suits preg-robbing ores. CIP keeps carbon wear lower and suits fast-leaching ores. The right choice depends on the ore and the plant.

What size activated carbon is used in CIL and CIP?

Most plants use 6×12 or 8×16 US mesh coconut shell carbon, chosen to match the inter-stage screens.

Why is coconut shell carbon used for gold recovery?

It is very hard, which limits breakage and gold loss, and its fine pore structure adsorbs gold-cyanide well. See FM MAXGOLD.

Read more: Gold recovery: the role of activated carbon in the mining industry · Your gold mine is losing gold and your carbon supplier might be why

Recent blog posts

Pressure filter vessels used for water pretreatment before reverse osmosis

November 3, 2026

Activated Carbon for RO Pretreatment: How to Protect Your Membranes

Reverse osmosis (RO) membranes are the most expensive part of most water purification and desalination systems, and they are easily damaged. An activated carbon filter in front of the RO is one of the simplest ways to protect them. This guide explains why, where the carbon goes and how to choose and run it. Why […]

Pieces of carbonised charcoal used to make activated carbon

November 3, 2026

Coconut Shell vs Coal-Based Activated Carbon: Which One Do You Need?

Most activated carbon is made from one of two raw materials: coconut shell or coal. Both are activated in the same way, with steam at high temperature, but they end up with different pore structures, hardness and purity. Choosing the right one can mean better results, longer carbon life and lower running costs. This guide […]

Aerial view of a wastewater treatment plant with clarifiers and aeration tanks

October 27, 2026

Activated Carbon for Industrial Wastewater Treatment: A Practical Guide

Industrial wastewater is harder to treat than sewage. It often carries chemicals that bacteria cannot break down, strong colour, and dissolved organics that keep COD (chemical oxygen demand) above discharge limits even after biological treatment. Activated carbon is one of the most effective ways to remove what the rest of the plant leaves behind. This […]

logo

First Molecule Support

FM Support
Hi, Thanks for visiting us.
We shall assist you in fulfilling your requirement.

FM Support
Firstly, let us know your region?